Skip to Content

Petty Theft Versus Grand Theft in California

Petty Theft Versus Grand Theft in California

California categorizes theft under two primary classifications: petty and grand. These classifications hinge on several factors, primarily the value of the stolen property but also the nature of the items taken.

The differentiation between petty and grand theft isn’t just academic; it influences everything from the potential charges to the severity of penalties, ranging from fines to significant imprisonment. Understanding what the prosecution must prove is vital for those accused of theft, as it allows them to begin forming a defense.

Still, the insights of a criminal defense attorney are indispensable. A knowledgeable lawyer can dissect the nuances of the case, from interpreting the laws and scrutinizing the evidence to crafting a tailored defense strategy. Given the complexities involved, anyone facing theft charges needs a competent legal representative who can navigate these murky waters effectively.

If you or someone you know is dealing with accusations in Santa Rosa, please schedule a consultation with Law Offices of Evan E. Zelig, P.C. by calling us at (707) 418-5352 or contacting us online.

Examining California’s General Theft Law

Theft, as defined by California Penal Code § 484(a), encompasses stealing, taking, carrying, leading, or driving away property belonging to another. This legal definition extends beyond physical appropriation to include deception or misrepresentation to misappropriate property—whether that property has been entrusted to the accused or outright belongs to someone else.

Theft charges have several key elements that the prosecution must prove beyond a reasonable doubt:

  • Possession. The defendant took possession of property owned by someone else. This possession does not necessarily mean permanent control but must involve some exercise of control or dominion over the property.
  • Lack of consent. The property owner did not give consent for the taking.
  • Intent to deprive. The defendant intended to permanently deprive the property owner of the item or for a period that would deny the owner a significant portion of its value or enjoyment.
  • Movement or keeping property. The defendant moved the property or kept it for any time, however brief.

These elements form the backbone of a theft charge and must all be present for a conviction. For anyone accused of theft, these points also highlight potential areas for defense, such as disputing intent or the fact of possession.

A Look at Petty Theft

Petty theft, as outlined in California Penal Code § 490.2, refers to taking property valued at no more than $950. This definition serves as a threshold for distinguishing between petty and grand theft, which involves higher-value items.

Penalties for Petty Theft

The penalties for petty theft in California can vary significantly based on the value of the stolen property and the circumstances.

Below are the possible confinement terms and fines:

  • Property valued at under $50. When the value of the stolen property does not exceed $50, the offense can be a misdemeanor or an infraction at the prosecutor's discretion. If charged as an infraction, the individual faces a fine of up to $250.
  • Property valued at $950 or less. In cases where the value of the stolen property is between $50 and $950, the offense is typically a misdemeanor. The standard penalties for this range include a fine of up to $1,000 and/or up to six months in county jail.
  • Petty theft with prior convictions. If an individual has prior convictions for certain serious or violent felonies, as specified under California law, they may face enhanced penalties for a petty theft charge. These penalties include 16 months or two or three years in county jail.

A Detailed Exploration of Grand Theft

Grand theft in California is a more severe theft charge defined under California Penal Code § 487. This charge is applicable under specific circumstances that elevate the theft's severity compared to petty theft.

The differentiation between petty theft and grand theft is primarily based on several threshold values and circumstances:

  • Property value. The value of the property taken exceeds $950.
  • Specific items. Regardless of their value, certain items such as food, agricultural products, or animals specifically prepared for sale or market can qualify an offense as grand theft.
  • Employee theft. If an employee steals from their employer and the aggregate value of the stolen property amounts to $950 or more over 12 months, it qualifies as grand theft.
  • Direct theft. The act of taking property directly from another person—regardless of the value—can escalate a theft to grand theft.
  • Specific property types. The theft of certain types of property, notably automobiles and firearms, is automatically classified as grand theft, irrespective of their exact value.

Penalties for Grand Theft

The penalties for grand theft are notably stiffer than petty theft, reflecting the more significant potential harm or loss caused by such offenses.

A grand theft conviction can result in the following:

  • Firearm theft. Theft involving a firearm is particularly serious and can result in 16 months, two years, or three years in state prison.
  • Property over $950. If the stolen property’s value exceeds $950 and does not involve a firearm, the penalty can range from up to one year in county jail to potentially 16 months, two years, or three years in county jail.

Navigating the Justice System with Legal Help

The complexity of theft laws and the potential consequences of a conviction make it essential to have competent legal representation. An attorney can navigate the legal system, challenge the prosecution's evidence, and argue for reduced penalties or even dismissal of charges.

At Law Offices of Evan E. Zelig, P.C., we understand the nuances of criminal defense and know how to seek just outcomes for our clients in Santa Rosa. Please contact us at (707) 418-5352.